Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood by
Marjane Satrapi is a graphic novel and memoir of a young girl who grew up in
Iran amidst the Islamic Revolution and war with Iraq. The graphic novel
provides insight into Iranian culture and provides a means for students to
examine issues of global conflict in a way that they can relate to the
character through both words and illustrations. Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood is a graphic novel that would
be worth teaching in the classroom because it is allows students the
opportunity to peer into the life a young person living in a different time,
place, and culture, and the graphic novel offers a unique structure that both
excites and challenges students.
I
would use Persepolis: The Story of a
Childhood in my classroom because it provides a unique medium for reading
that might encourage reluctant readers to get on board with a book that is
complex and examines some tough topics. While some readers may look at a
graphic novel and dismiss its illustrations as juvenile, graphic novels are
unique in the sense that "the illustrations enrich and extend the
text" (Bucher & Hinton 337). For example, as readers read the words on
the page and look at the images depicted with those words, they may get a
different understanding of the meaning than if they had simply read the words.
Satrapi does this in her graphic novel as she writes,"After a long sleep
of 2,500 years, the revolution has finally awakened the people," yet the
illustration below the text shows people who appear to be dead rather than
sleeping and lying in the streets (44). Furthermore, Bucher and Hinton say that
"readers must not only decode the words and the illustrations but must
also identify what is happening between the visual sequences" (337).
Therefore, graphic novels present a challenge to readers as they must make some
predictions and interact with the story as it jumps from scene to scene. Furthermore,
graphic novels are visual, which will appeal to visual learners and learners
who may be intimidated by reading a wordy novel. The genre overall would be
useful in the classroom.
I
would also use Persepolis: The Story of a
Childhood as a multicultural work that would serve as a window for students
to see a lifestyle that is different than their own. In general, multicultural
literature allows readers to better understand other cultures and connect with
people who are different than them; reading books about different parts of the
world also helps eliminate stereotypes about different cultures (Bucher &
Hinton 36-7). In their book about using young adult literature in the
classroom, Bucher and Hinton suggest using Persepolis:
The Story of a Childhood as a way "to provide insight into global
conflicts and power struggles" (344). With this in mind, the book could be
taught along with a social studies lesson about global conflict or the history
of Iran. I think it would be an interesting topic for students to explore
because they are bombarded with images of the Middle East that represent war,
terrorism, enemies, and religious fanaticism. While the story does deal with these
types of topics, I think it would be beneficial to students to learn about a
character who is not so different from themselves who is in the Middle East and
possibly expel some of their preconceived notions that they may associate with
people who live in the Middle East. Marji deals with feeling lost, losing loved
ones, rebelling, and dealing with fear, which are all universal struggles that
students will be able to connect with their own lives (Satrapi 71, 65, 117,
140).
Overall,
Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood by
Marjane Satrapi is a book that would be beneficial to students to read and
explore in the classroom because it presents a different kind of novel that I
think students would enjoy reading, and it also presents a character who lives
in a different part of the world and has a unique perspective. The genre of the
graphic novel is not widely used in classrooms; however, the genre has a great
deal of potential for reluctant readers and lower level readers. There is value
in utilizing different forms of literature and exposing students to a variety
of genres. Perhaps a student who would not enjoy reading about the conflict in
Iran in a history book would be interested in reading a graphic novel about the
same topic.
Works Cited
Bucher, Katherine, and KaaVonia Hinton. Young Adult Literature: Exploration,
Evaluation, and Appreciation. 3rd
ed. Boston: Pearson, 2014. Print.
Satrapi, Marjane. Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood. Paris: Pantheon, 2003. Print.
"I would use Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood in my classroom because it provides a unique medium for reading that might encourage reluctant readers to get on board with a book that is complex and examines some tough topics."
ReplyDeleteI really love the idea that you point out that not only will it encourage reluctant readers to read, but also to read a text that encourages them to struggle with complex ideas and decode pictures to arrive at an understanding about the text that is their own.
I also love how you used the "window" opportunity and applied it to multicultural diversity. I agree that it is completely necessary to create those windows and mirrors in relation to multicultural attitudes, but I would not have thought about applying that term to it until you said it. Thanks!
I am going to have to read both the original and the graphic novel. I wish I could take a class on Middle Eastern literature; I think the students have an interest and curiosity about the Middle East. I have wanted to do a unit on Middle Eastern literature for a few years and have been slowly accruing ideas. Thanks for sharing this and I will definitely check it out.
ReplyDeleteI love how you justified not only the use of Persepolis, but graphic novels in general in the classroom.
ReplyDeleteYou made strong points of how the text would help to encourage reluctant readers and used Bucher and Hinton to really add claim to graphic novels as a whole. Great entry. I also loved how you tied in the importance of texts providing students mirrors. Thanks for sharing.