All readers, including students, read for a variety of
reasons. Depending on the circumstances, Sarah Dyer explains that students may
read for efferent or aesthetic purposes—for information or pleasure
respectively (Dyer 37). Reluctant readers
may find it difficult to read a classic for either purpose because, as noted by
Jonathan Ostenson and Rachel Wadham, readers need something familiar in a test
or they may become alienated from its meaning (Ostenson 6). Reluctant readers
need young adult literature and innovative assignments in order to become
engaged in the reading process. Katherine Bucher and KaaVonia Hinton note that
there is value in knowing why students do not enjoy reading but it is just as
valuable to find ways to motivate readers (Bucher 69).
By providing recreational reading times and utilizing alternatives to
traditional book reports, reluctant readers will become more motivated to
engage in texts such as Louisa May Alcott’s Little
Women.
Choice
is an exceptional motivational tool and the providing students with
opportunities to read texts of their choice for pleasure is important. Ostenson
and Wadham explain that motivation matters (Ostenson 10).
As Dyer explains in her article, students are busy with extra-curricular and
other activities outside of school that prevent leisure reading (Dyer 41). Using class time to
allow students to read whatever they choose provides a motivational tool to
encourage reluctant readers to start reading. Reading for pleasure in the
classroom allows students to build their confidence with a variety of texts.
Reluctant readers need an opportunity to discover a love for reading in order
to benefit from assigned texts like Little
Women. By building their confidence in reading, students will be more
inclined to attempt texts outside of their comfort zones.
In
addition to opportunities to read for aesthetic purposes, reluctant readers
need engaging assignments that are in forms they are already acquainted with.
Ostenson and Wadham note that as students build their prior knowledge and
experience with reading, students increase their ability to engage in the texts (Ostenson 11). As motivation is
key to encouraging reluctant readers to participate in discussions and
evaluations of texts, incorporating nontraditional written assignments into the
curriculum is paramount. Dyer explains that “any assignment that arises from
the study of a book should be authentic with a real audience” (Dyer 41). Blogs, social media
pages, and letters to authors are written assignments that are more familiar to
students.
Dyer notes that students
who were asked to “create blogs, Facebook walls, or Twitter feeds for a
character in their book . . . were immediately comfortable with the rhetorical
context of this real-life writing assignment” (Dyer 41). Little Women, for example, is a text in
which students can be asked to perform a number of tasks using new media
sources. Students may be asked to become a March sister and Tweet to each other
while Beth and Father are ill. Students could choose to write a series of blogs
from Laurie’s point of view while he is away at college. The entire class can
provide entries for a collective version of the “Pickwick Portfolio” and copies
can be made available to the student body. Students are familiar with blogs and
Twitter and will enjoy creating a joint paper for fun. Each task provides
students with an opportunity to explore the world in which the characters in Little Women live and be able to relate
character experiences to their own.
Allowing reluctant
readers to build confidence in their skills through independent reading and
producing alternative written assignments will encourage students to actively
participate in assigned readings such as Little
Women. Independent reading times allow students to build their confidence
in reading and encourages students to read for pleasure. It also demonstrates
the importance of reading beyond classrooms and grades. Using written forms
that students use on a daily basis provides a comfort level reluctant readers
can grow in. Students will be more inclined to discuss topics and texts if they
have a real audience they are addressing. Reluctant readers are found across
all reading levels. Educators must adapt to the needs of their students to
foster a love of reading in all students.
Works Cited
Bucher, Katherine and KaaVonia Hinton. Young Adult
Literature: Exploration, Evaluation, and Appreciation. 3rd ed. Boston:
Pearson, 2014. Print.
Dyer, Sarah. "Read This, Not That: Why and How I'll Use
Young Adult Literature in My Classroom." The Virginia English Journal
64.1 (2014): 33-43.
Ostenson, Jonathan and Rachel Wadham. "Young Adult
Literature and the Common Core: A Surprisingly Good Fit." American
Secondary Education 41.1 (2012): 4-13.
"Choice is an exceptional motivational tool and the providing students with opportunities to read texts of their choice for pleasure is important."
ReplyDeleteI cannot express to you how happy it made me to read this passage. I feel like English teachers sometimes get so wrapped up in forcing students to read what we enjoy that we forget our students are autonomous and need to choose their own path. You are absolutely correct in saying that choice is a great motivational tool. If we as teachers are trying to create readers that love to read forcing students to read books that they dislike, cannot connect with, or cannot understand is the best way to demotivate them and make them dislike reading in general. Thank you, Ashley, for such a thought-provoking response.
As we participate in this blog, I find it interesting that you wrote the following: "Students will be more inclined to discuss topics and texts if they have a real audience they are addressing." I know publishing my essays creates a heightened sense of awareness; although, it does not particularly change what I write. I realize that most of us are not reluctant readers, but busy ones. I find that alternate methods of writing inspire students as well. If they perceive an audience, whether is providing feedback or creating, high school students do work harder to show off for their peers. I agree that educators must "adapt to the needs of their students to foster a love of reading in all students." Who wouldn't agree? Being adaptable, flexible, and open to change is what keeps a teacher sane in the classroom. If you listen, the students will tell what inspires them, and a good teacher will try to pull a Gumby to stretch to make it work.
ReplyDeleteGreat discussion here. I especially love Dawn's comments about having a real audience. This idea is big in composition studies right now, in part because of what Dawn says here.
ReplyDelete